Hidden in the middle of Dartmoor, it takes a special trip to go to Gidleigh Park; but it’s well worth the effort. In 2009 I paid my first visit to Michael Caines’ 2-Michelin starred restaurant and was well impressed by the quality of the food and service, and decided that I simply had to return to this special place on my week-long gourmet holiday down in SW England.
After the disappointing visit to Vineyard at Stockcross earlier in the week, I got a bit skeptical about another Relais & Chateaux place. After raving about Gidleigh Park, it would have been a disaster if the place didn’t live to my expectation, let alone the expectation of my American friends who came over to the UK specifically for the gourmet week. Also the brilliant dinner at Le Champignon Sauvage in Cheltenham the night before pushed that bar even higher.
The tasting menus came in two choices: the seasonal one or the classic one. Both looked equally appetising. These were the dishes featured in the two menus:
- Red Mullet, with fennel salad
- Tartlet of Quail and Quail’s Eggs, with onion confit, black truffle and smoked bacon and a light quail jus
- Loch Duart Salmon Confit, herb puree, lentils, horseradish and Parmesan cream sauce
- Warm Pigeon Salad, with apple, hazelnuts and roasted foie gras
- Local Venison, with braised belly pork, chestnut puree, roast winter vegetables and raisins soaked in jasmine tea
- Selection of British cheeses (Sharpham Elmhurst, Little Wallop and Devon Blue)
- Apple Jelly, vanilla foam
- Hot prune and Armagnac Souffle (Prune and Armagnac ice-cream)
Classic Tasting Menu
- Tartar of Marinated Tuna, with scallops and lime, Oscietra caviar, soused turnip and beetroot, wasabi cream, honey and soy vinaigrette
- Terrine of Foie Gras, with Madeira jelly, truffled green bean salad
- Brixham Turbot, leek, wild mushrooms and chive butter sauce
- Cornish Duckling, with joney and spices and an apple galette
- Dartmoor Lamb, with boulangere potato and confit shoulder, fennel puree and a tapenade jus
- Selection of Devonshire cheeses (Sharpham Celeste, Sloe Tavy, Quickes mature Cheddar and Harbourne Blue)
- Orange Tartlet, orange confit sauce
- Caramel and Cardamon Parfait (Milk chocolate mousse with nougatine and a cardamom foam)
Although both tasting menus looked so tempting, we decided to opt for the a la carte menu, simply because there were some equally wonderful dishes there.
For starter, I opted for the Quail Raviolo – this was one large raviolo filled with quail meat, with truffled quail egg yolk on the side, and a herb puree precisely spreaded out onto the dish. The whole dish looked like a beautiful piece of artwork.
Darcy opted for the Loch Duart Salmon, which was served with caviar, salmon jelly and cucumber, and drizzled with honey, soy and wasabi and Greek yoghurt vinaigrettes. It was another dish that was beautifully presented, and the quality of the salmon just completely wowed her.
Bob opted for the Red Mullet with Thai puree and fennel salad – I recommended this to him, based on the Brixham Scalliops with Thai puree that I had last year, which had a wonderful fragance that brought my memory all the way back to Thailand! Russell had his usual choice of Terrine of Foie Gras with rhubarb compote, rhubard and lemon grass jelly, pickled rhubard and girolle mushrooms. Both dishes were precisely executed.
Everyone at the table had thoroughly enjoyed the first course. There was a sigh of relief for me.
For the main course, Darcy once again went for the fish – this time it’s the Boudin of John Dory with Langoustine, served with apple and ginger puree, pink grapefruit, chicken and vanilla jus; while Russell went for the Saddle of Venison accompanied by braised belly of pork, chestnut puree, roast vegetables and raisons soaked in jasmine tea. Bob and I decided to go for the Cornish Duckling with star anise, orange braised chicory and orange scented sauce – so essentially a glamourous Canard a L’orange!
For dessert, the choices included Selection of Cheeses, Passion Fruit Mousse (which came with rice pudding ice-cream and a coconut tuile), and the Hot Prune and Armagnac Souffle featured in the tasting menu. However, Bob decided to go for the Hot Apple Tarte which was served with vanilla ice-cream and Somerset cider coulis – being a tee-total, the coulis was omitted from the dish.
I opted for the Banana Parfait with chocolate and lime sorbet, which I had the year before. It didn’t disappoint.
The winning dessert, must be Russell’s Trio of Chocolates: This consisted of hazelnut and milk chocolate parfait, dark chocolate mousse on a chocolate sable biscuit, and white chocolate ice-cream. A real dream dessert for any chocoholics.
The service throughout the evening was efficient and friendly, without over-imposing which can be the downside of so many of the Michelin restaurants. After dinner, we moved to the comfortable sitting room and sank into the sofa to enjoy the petit fours and coffee. What a pleasant way to finish off the evening – the hardest activity was to finally drag ourselves upstairs back to the room after such an unforgettable meal.
If I really have to find one fault in Gidleigh Park this time, it would have been the aperitif. They were just a little bit too generous on the creme de cassis in the kir royale – making the drink a bit sweeter than usual. But then this is very much a personal taste, and if I make a fuss about this, I’d risk myself turning into a grumpy old man!
The meal may not have all the fancy tricks that Heston Blumenthal would have at the Fat Duck, but it’s genuinely well executed and after scoring a nearly perfect 19/20 last year, I am ready to give Gidleigh Park this time to a perfect 20/20.
Address: Gidleigh Park Hotel & Restaurant, Chagford, Devon, TQ13 8HH, United Kingdom
Telephone: +44 (0)1647 432367
Opening Hours: Daily for lunch and dinner
Total: 20/20 [Based on visit in March 2010]